By Jack Cumming

This article is addressed to the leaders and future leaders of the senior living industry. You know who you are. You may be the CEO of a large multi-facility enterprise. Perhaps you are the leader of an influential advisory organization that advises those CEOs of large multi-facility enterprises. You may take pride in an annual conference that brings clients and prospective clients together to discuss the future of the industry.

Optimism Reigns

Lately, that future has seemed bright. After all, the post-World War II babies, born in the late 1940s or early 1950s, are now aging into beds/units in your or your clients’ communities. A rising demographic wave lifts all ships.

You may be thinking, “The ship I captain is ready to ride that wave to prosperity.” You may also be thinking that you’ll surf that wave into your retirement. After all, most of you leaders are boomers yourselves. Of course, you know what they want. You’re likely one yourself.

Hidden in that rosy picture is an uncomfortable reality. Senior living has never reached its potential. Most people prefer to age in place in their own homes. That’s often a single-family home that they own. Although you work in the congregate-living industry, you probably don’t want its product any more than most Americans want it; i.e., they don’t. That’s a challenge, and it leads to the premise of this article.

Coast or Act?

Do you want a challenge, or do you prefer to coast? Coasting means deflecting negative press with spin and actively supporting industry lobbying organizations. Facing a challenge means identifying why senior living is less preferred than aging in place and seeking changes to make communal living more acceptable. It’s not difficult.

It takes courage and capital. My experience is that great leaders love a challenge more than they want an outsized paycheck or popular recognition. Most leaders, even the very top leaders, prefer to coast and love the limelight, if only within the industry itself.

The Challenge

Let’s be frank. Today, most CCRCs look like Perkins-Eastman’s cookie-cutter models. Non-city communities have porte-cochères adorning block structures with massive public areas. The plans come with attractive drawings void of people. And that’s just the start. The architecture for the finances is also cookie-cutter.

Increasingly, prospective residents are questioning the structure. Financing involves negative net assets for many not-for-profits and a lack of transparency for many for-profits. The opportunities for creativity are beckoning. Active Adult 55+ and Margaritavilles are trying, but they can’t quite get there.

Many residents are asked to give up homeownership to move into a community with ownership exercised by not-for-profit executives with little skin in the game beyond employment. Residents usually commit for life.

That’s an unraveling late in life of the American Dream of homeownership. Some think old people don’t want ownership, but few senior housing executives are willing to sell their homes to move into a community owned and governed without them.

Self-Governance Is No Solution

Clearly, elder housing has a trust problem. You’d think that resident governance might invoke trust. It doesn’t. Self-governed old age communities are rare, and they often flounder on the rocks of dominant personalities lacking perspective, know-how, prudence, or sound judgment.

Most resident leaders are popular and imagine that popularity lifts them locally above those of greater wisdom. Of course, they themselves often equate popularity with merit and wisdom. Part of their popularity is that they never confront unpopular, difficult truths.

They are “get-along” folks. That’s common in corporate leadership ranks, too, but never as openly as among residents.

Too much self-governance can be disastrous.

Imagining

Here we run out of options. No one comes to mind with the stature and capital to make senior living trustworthy, who is now doing so. My own thinking, which I would want to hone in constructive conversation with others, is that the newly emerging business model of the benefit corporation may be part of the solution.

A benefit corporation is like a not-for-profit in limiting its purpose and powers in its constituent articles of incorporation to what is beneficial for its purpose. For instance, consider the purpose of a not-for-profit senior living organization. It might commit to house older people in a way that relieves the distress of aging.

Distress here might refer to growing frailty, vulnerability due to gullibility, and difficulty getting suitable care when and as needed. A benefit corporation can commit to the same purpose but with access to equity investment and meaningful board and management accountability.

What are some of the conditions and mission to which a consumer-oriented sponsor of a benefit corporation might commit in order to competitively upend today’s not-for-profits? Here are some conceivable constraints that came to mind:

  • Return for equity investors, either as net worth or dividends, to be limited to no more than a risk premium of 15% over debt yield above the average cost of debt funding for the community. Equity investors deserve a risk premium, but they shouldn’t be greedy. Residents are the mission.
  • Residents to be given first opportunity to provide equity funding once the community opens. Before then, prospective residents who have paid deposits receive the first equity investor privilege.
  • Voting shares to be limited to residents who invest equity and no one else.
  • Voting to be proportional to the par value of the resident’s equity investment shares.

Other commitments can be added, subject only to how competitive the sponsoring entrepreneur, which might be an existing not-for-profit, wants to be and to the restrictions of law. These ideas are presented to illustrate how this might work. It’s obviously far more complex than this suggests. LeadingAge, or someone else, might easily develop document templates responsive to the opportunity.

Conclusion

The senior living industry is now frozen in stagnation. There’s talk of artificial intelligence and robotics, but no one I know of is doing anything meaningful to achieve a competitive advantage.

Meanwhile, the industry lags its potential; it takes it for granted that average age and impairment acuity have risen with time. The talk is of an emerging asset class that offers higher percentage returns, while in truth, in a larger context, the path to high profits is volume and not returns that would make Shylock smile.

To put it in other terms, on the whole, the senior living industry has long been coasting, bemoaning the difficulty of attracting good staff, and hoping for the saving grace of baby boomers moving into units that would otherwise have challenged occupancy.

The obverse side of that happy coin is the opportunity that presents itself for anyone with the discernment and capital to upend the status quo and to help make senior living the industry that many dream it is, but that in reality is only a dream for a better future.

Can senior living continue to thrive after the boomer bulge has gone to its reward? Will the industry then look anything like the industry today? What firms will then be the respected voice of aging?

Note: The inspiration for this reflection, which seems very foreign to the conventionality of the senior living industry, especially its not-for-profit sector, came from an interview with AMD Chair and CEO, Dr. Lisa Su, on the “Future of AI and Leadership,” https://youtu.be/-sKAMB10eh0.

Why, I thought, doesn’t senior living have leaders like this. Dr. Su lifted AMD’s valuation from $2 Billion to over a trillion. The stock price then was under $4. As I write this, it’s over $600. Not too shabby. Who in senior living is capable of that? Are you?